The Iraq War Was Wrong Blog

The world has many wrongs, and many wars, but there's only one wrong Iraq war.

"A wrong war like during the Iraq war was cannot just be sitted idly by by." --The Proprietor

Thursday, August 26, 2004

You question me, I answer you (Huh? dept.)

Ok, I'm have to say, every once in a while I get a letter that makes me go "huh??". For typical example, I relly don't quite know waht to make of this letter.



Dear Ms./Mr. "iraqwarwrong" whoever you are:

I came across your site while web-surfing and felt compelled to write
you. As a pacifist, I've been through a lot these last few years.
But once I realized what you're trying to do with your site (it's
all oh so subtle), I found it more vile, and juvenile, than just
about anything. (And that's saying a lot.)

I have a question for you, and I want you to think seriously (don't
just react - *think*.) Do you feel good about yourself, doing what
you're doing? Do you think you are contributing something
*positive* to the world, or just adding to the sewer of negativity
and xenophobia, dehumanization and violence?

The question that screams out is: Is war really the appropriate
subject for your.... (highly dubious) efforts and "talents"?

Do you even understand what war is?

Although I wear my convictions proudly and do not hide them,
believe me, this is not a partisan issue. There is untold human
suffering, death, and destruction which has been unleashed. And in
the face of it, what do you do? For years, novelists and poets have
chronicled the horror, the carnage, the chaos, the hell of war. (And
make no mistake, that IS what it is. Have you ever been through it
*yourself*, or do you lead the kind of sheltered existence that, I
suspect, you do? It is NOT some "fun" video game for you to
cheerlead and excuse away.)

So what is *your* reaction? Just that: Fun and games. It's all just
a big "joke" to you, isn't it? A pile of corpses, and you get on top,
and laugh. Ha ha Iraqis. Ha ha Afghanis.

Do you feel clever?

There is a world out there. Learn about it. Try to show some
empathy. I suspect you are young, and I suspect you have been
cynicalized by your upbringing and the irony of our age. In a
way, I cannot blame you completely for this, but nevertheless you
must take responsibility for what you leave of yourself in this world.

And what you are leaving of yourself, isn't pretty. It is disgusting
and small. Very, very small. There are rightwingers out there who,
wrongheaded and self-serving though they may be, at least make a
pretense of attempting rational argument. I don't know what you
think you are accomplishing by doing what you're doing, but rest
assured, it is not what you think. It is far, far less.

You are saying more about yourself, and your soul, than about
anything else. Ask yourself if what you are showing to the world,
is what you want the world to learn about you. Ask yourself what,
and who, is served by your attitude and approach to everything.
How much suffering do you want on your hands, and if you can't
defend your position straightforwardly - well, what does that say?

Think about it. PLEASE.

Peace, and understanding,

Minerva L. Gunderson
Lansing


Anyone know what, in the heck this weird lady is talking about? I'm at a loss as to how to respond (here). She seems to of written teh wrong sight (rather surrealistic letter)(it's like she doesn't understand/talking about my sight at all). How's this response--


Dear Minerva Mrs. Gunderson,

WE're all on teh same side(here). I dont relly see where we
have a dispute . Maybe did you confuse me with (someone else)?
I'ts ok/it happens. I was in Missouri once (stopover), it was
nice (alittle hot)(from what I could tell inside airport). Are
you a Cardinals fan? Albert Pujols-the BEST (OPS skyhigh).
Anyway, I'm glad we have you on are side, you write beautifuly/
persuasively(from what I coudl scan/glean). You should do letters
to editor etc. Keep on em!

iraqwarwrong.blogspot.com


Ok I just sent it off. Obviously there was some mixup here, but really,s he's all right in my book (well meaning), We all (I think) get alittle addled from dealing with dhingers all day long.

7 Comments:

At 8/26/2004 11:54 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Tread lightly your very SOUL is at risk! (I think she actually believes you may have sold it or something.)

Bob

 
At 8/26/2004 12:07 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

What an asshole. Fuck that guy.

 
At 8/26/2004 1:15 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is not heartening that Donald Rumsfeld's worldview is determined by capitalist interests which lead to the resurgence of White Supremacist ideologies. This suggests that the American state, with its unelected president, venal Supreme Court, silent Congress, gutted Bill of Rights and compliant media leads our attention to a McCarthyism which threatens everything we hold dear. As Norman Mailer pointed out, Colin Powell's parade of lies can be regarded as the predatory imperialist aims outlined by the crypto-fascist Project for a New American Century. Nevertheless, the 15-minute speech delivered Monday night by President Bush belies justifications given by the world's leading apologists for the essential Western imperial interests.

 
At 8/26/2004 2:24 PM, Blogger iraqwarwrong said...

I couldn't agree more! More to the point, however, let me say this:

As Norman Mailer pointed out, the influence of Leo Strauss is solid evidence of the police state which has come to pass. Since the collapse of the Soviet Union, the deal between the Department of Defense and Halliburton unit Kellogg, Brown & Root leads our attention to the result of a pre-fascist atmosphere in America. It is not heartening that Americanism as an ideology can be seen in the light of the apparent fabrications which lead to an act of international violence that exceeds even those of the "liberal" Bill Clinton. On the other hand, the Pax Americana of the future can be regarded as a McCarthyism which threatens everything we hold dear.

 
At 8/26/2004 2:27 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Weeelll shiiiit! It looks like Chomsky found yore little old blog. What a load of horse dung! Let's all play how many lefty cliche's can I pack in a paragraph.

Bob

 
At 8/26/2004 4:52 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

At first I thought Minerva Gunderson was a made-up name, but upon second reading of her letter, I realized she is the real Minerva, incarnated in our time as a Mrs. Gunderson of Lansing. The tip-off is that she ends her letter "Peace, and understanding." A few thousand years ago, she might have said "peace by wise strategy, and understanding rather than rage in war," but even though she has now slipped wearily into an unrealistic and not-so-wise pacifism (perhaps wisdom is hard to maintain for several millenia), and sporting a Swedish surname (a godly superior culture, you'll agree) I'm sure it's her. Take it down a notch, Minerva.

-Alias

 
At 8/26/2004 5:24 PM, Blogger iraqwarwrong said...

Well Alias didn't quite understand your point about goddess/ but you could be rigth I can't say either way (whether she made up her name) as the Internet provides anonimity for her. (She could of adopted some moniker)(people sometimes do, on internet). All I know is I reproduce the letter in entirety/ you decide.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

Listed on 
BlogShares Blog Directory & Search engine